Monochrome photograph of a person sleeping on a stone ledge next to a decorative fountain. Copyright Urban Camera.
Commentary

Politics: Make Your Voice Heard

Our days are filled with reports of demonstrations, of war, of poverty and of endless riches. Disregarding the fantasy, the conspiracy theories, the rage-baiting, there is barely a single form of massed media – be it print, radio, cable news, internet or social media – which does not cover all of these themes in a constant stream of reports, a relentless reminder of where we stand, who wins, who loses, and who is responsible for many of the major problems attacking society today. Everyone has their own villain, and some of those blamed have nothing to do with the current situation whatsoever; they were either never there, or their participation, their complicity, has merely been invented by those looking for a excuse for their own failings or inaction; the politics of blame attribution by finger-pointing to dodge the blame. Regardless of which news source the eager reader uses, they will be confronted with the same ideals as have followed us down through history, despite all attempts to change society: feudalism; capitalism; the right of kings is the way forward; the rich are those who have the power; politics used to protect those with wealth and power.

In theory the power lies with the People. This is something we are constantly being reminded of: governing for the People by the People; elected by the People; We the People. Anyone who does not know the preamble to the Constitution of the United States of America – and this appears to be many elected politicians – does not appreciate the power which should lie in the hands of the People. It reads:

We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.

The truth is a different beast entirely. Reality casts a shadow over these fine words and obliterates not only their meaning, but the revered memory of those who wrote them. Article One of the French Constitution – rewritten from that of 1789, confirmed in 1946, ratified on 4 October 1958 and further enhanced in 2004 – reads:

France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic. It shall ensure the equality of all citizens before the law, without distinction of origin, race or religion. It shall respect all beliefs. It shall be organised on a decentralised basis.

In the United Kingdom the debate over a codified Constitution is still being bandied about through the corridors of power, a report from 2015 being the apparent last real attempt to take the work seriously, to place the countries comprising the United Kingdom on a level with other civilised countries and societies. The Spanish Constitution was enacted in 1978.

What all of these countries have in common is not only desire – and a lawfully enacted provision for all but the United Kingdom – but the need for the regulation of a society for the People, constituted on the power of the People, and enacted at their will through elected officials. The constitutions speak of equality, of social matters, of the law, of religion, of politics. They are all, effectively, written and ratified documents for a social society of people working and living together, without harm being done to any through fault of their educational level, their religion, their ethnic roots, their political beliefs. And every single one of these constitutions is being stamped on and ignored by the governments elected to uphold them. Were that not so, then none of the four items listed in the opening sentence to this paper would be relevant, would be in the news, would be on people’s minds.

That there are a few with so much wealth they cannot hope to spend it in a thousand lifetimes, and whose volume is only reduced by a sudden dive on the stock exchange, or a well-timed divorce, breaches the ideal of these constitutions. That extreme poverty exists in rich societies pledging social care, welfare and the Rights of all, breaches these constitutions. That wars are enacted without any consideration for those forced onto its front lines, sacrificing their lives for what is often merely a commercial cause, and without the explicit approval of those legal and legislative organs charged with oversight and the power of discrimination, breaches these constitutions. It is only the Right to demonstrate which does not break the constitutional rules: the Right to free speech; to a free opinion unsullied by force or suppression; the Right to gather and address those elected to a position of power and call them to order. And it is the Right to demonstrate which is being attacked by those who have constantly trodden on the provisions of their Constitution, and filled their own pockets with riches, rather than the causes which lead to demonstrations.

Little seems to have changed over the last decades, in the time since the new beginnings after the Second World War, when all governments professed the ideal of building new societies and avoiding the errors of the past. It is almost as if these words have no meaning, or a meaning that is not directly linked to what has been written and intended, but changed, mutilated according to the needs of some power-hungry entity.

If you clearly state what you mean, you’ll be locked up. If you don’t state it clearly enough for everyone to understand, there’s no point in saying anything at all.

Wolf Biermann in Ihr löscht das feuer mit Benzin (2026), 29 December 1963.

Governments will continue to suppression public opinion, the Right to speak out and to show disagreement with policies many see as hate-filled, many see as breaching the terms of their Constitution. The People will be forced out, will forced to continue taking to the streets and bringing attention to their plight, and the plight of others in our societies, to those who would be lord and master. No one is coming in on a great white charger, there is no alternative planet, we have but one life. And those who do not raise their voices, who do not demonstrate, who suffer in silence or believe that the elected few will make things better given the chance, merely contribute to making society worse, to bringing back dictators, feudal systems long abandoned by civilised people, to piling more riches upon those who already have enough.

Without the voice of the People, the Constitution is merely a sheet of well intentioned words, a tourist attraction, a figment of the imagination. Without the People demonstrating on the streets of their cities, disrupting the means of capitalism, calling their elected representatives out for their misdeeds and failings, there is no voice to be heard. Where there is no voice to be heard, nothing will be changed. The rich will get richer, the poorer will be driven further down into poverty, education will be dumbed down to non-existence, health care will die, society will rot. And nothing will get better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Copyright Urban Camera.